His shoulders lifted and fell. “Books are doors,” he said. “And when you can’t leave a place… you learn to love doors.”
The phrase made something in me unclench.
“What do you read?” I asked.
“Whatever I can find,” he said. “Old newspapers. Sermons. Sometimes books I borrow when no one’s looking.”
I hesitated, then asked, “Have you read Shakespeare?”
His eyes widened as if I’d offered him a treasure. “Yes, miss,” he said, and the excitement in his voice startled me. “There’s an old copy in the library no one touches. I read it at night when the house sleeps.”
“Which plays?”
“Hamlet. Romeo and Juliet. The Tempest.” His voice warmed with each title. “The Tempest is my favorite.”
“Why?” I asked, leaning forward as much as my chair allowed, hungry in a way I hadn’t felt in years.
Isaiah hesitated, then spoke with careful intensity. “Because everyone calls Caliban a monster,” he said, “but the story shows he was taken. His home claimed. His person named savage so someone else can feel righteous.”
The words hung between us like a blade and a plea.
“Who is the monster, then?” I whispered.
Isaiah’s eyes locked on mine. “That’s the question,” he said.
Something inside me shifted. A small, stubborn part of me—the part that had survived twelve rejections—stood up straight.
“Isaiah,” I said, “I don’t think you’re a brute.”
His face tightened as if he were trying not to believe me.
“I think you’re a person forced into an impossible situation,” I continued, “just like I am.”
His eyes shone suddenly, and he looked away quickly, ashamed of tears.
“Thank you, miss,” he murmured.
“Call me Clara,” I said, because I needed the world to change at least one inch. “When we are alone.”
He shook his head, horrified. “I shouldn’t.”
“Nothing about this is proper,” I said, voice sharp. “If we’re to do what my father demands, then I refuse to let it be done with lies and titles that make you smaller.”
His jaw worked. Then, slowly, he nodded once. “Clara,” he said, and my name sounded different in his mouth—gentle, steady, real.
“And you should know,” he added, and the courage in his voice made my throat tighten, “I don’t think you’re unmarriageable.”
I blinked.
“The men who rejected you were fools,” he said simply. “Any man who can’t see past a chair to the person inside doesn’t deserve you.”
No one had spoken to me like that in four years.
My hands trembled. “Will you agree to my father’s plan?” I asked softly.
Isaiah didn’t hesitate. “Yes,” he said. “I’ll protect you. I’ll care for you. And I’ll try to be worthy of you.”
I exhaled like someone releasing a rope they’d been gripping too long. “And I’ll try,” I said, “to make this bearable for both of us.”
We sealed it with a handshake. His enormous palm swallowed my hand, but his touch was careful, as if I were made of glass and dignity.
When my father returned, his relief was immediate and guilty.
A small ceremony was held on April 1st, 1856, inside our household, away from the eyes of Charleston society. It was not a legal marriage, because the law did not recognize Isaiah as a man with rights. That fact sat like poison under every prayer. My father read Bible verses and announced Isaiah’s new role: not property in the forge alone, but guardian of my welfare.
And in that announcement, my father did something unexpected. He told the household staff, white and enslaved alike, to treat Isaiah with respect in matters concerning me.
It was a thin kind of power, given by a man who still owned him. But it changed the air.
Isaiah was assigned a room adjacent to mine, connected by a door. Propriety was maintained like a curtain drawn over a cracked window.
The first weeks were awkward in a way that made my skin feel too tight. I had been cared for by women who spoke softly and avoided eye contact when my body required help. Now Isaiah had to assist me with tasks that felt humiliating even when done kindly.
But he approached everything with a gentleness that made shame harder to hold.
When he lifted me from chair to bed, he asked permission first.
“May I?” he would say, voice careful.
When he helped me dress, he kept his gaze averted as though my dignity were a fragile heirloom.
“I know this is uncomfortable,” I told him one morning, watching him reorganize my bookshelf after I mentioned—once—that I wished it were alphabetical.
He didn’t look up from the spines. “Yes, miss,” he said automatically, then corrected himself, almost smiling. “Yes… Clara.”
“And you didn’t choose this,” I said. “Neither did I.”
Isaiah knelt beside the shelf, and in that position—so large yet so contained—he looked less like a myth and more like a man tired of being shaped by other people’s fear.
“I’ve been enslaved my whole life,” he said quietly. “I’ve worked heat that would kill most men. I’ve been punished for mistakes made by others. I’ve watched family sold away like furniture.”
My throat tightened.
He gestured around my comfortable room. “Here, I get books. I get conversation. I get… you treating me like I have a mind.”
“Yet you’re still enslaved,” I said.
“Yes,” he answered, and the word held a world. “But I’d rather be here with someone who sees me than alone somewhere else with no one.”
The honesty made my chest ache.
By the end of April, we had a routine. Mornings he helped with my preparations and carried me when the chair couldn’t manage stairs. Then he returned to the forge. I handled household accounts. Afternoons we spent time together: sometimes I watched him work, fascinated by the way he turned iron into useful grace. Sometimes he read to me, stumbling at first but improving quickly as I corrected him gently.
One evening, I asked him to read poetry. Keats, because I needed beauty that wasn’t made of silk and cruelty.
His voice filled the room, deep and steady.
“A thing of beauty is a joy forever,” he read, and the words felt like a dare to the universe.
“Do you believe that?” I asked when he paused.
Isaiah considered. “I think beauty in memory lasts,” he said. “The thing itself might fade. But what it gave you… that remains.”
“What’s the most beautiful thing you’ve ever seen?” I asked, and the question felt childish, but I wanted to hear him speak of wonder.
He was quiet long enough that I began to regret asking. Then he said softly, “You.”
Heat rose to my face like a sudden flame.
“Yesterday at the forge,” he continued, voice firming, “covered in soot, sweating, laughing when you managed to bend the nail. That was beautiful.”
My heart stuttered.
“I shouldn’t have said that,” he added quickly, shame flashing.
“No,” I whispered, rolling my chair closer. “Say it again.”
Isaiah’s eyes met mine. “You are beautiful, Clara,” he said. “The chair doesn’t change it. The legs that don’t work don’t change it. You are brave and sharp-minded and kind. And anyone who couldn’t see that was blind.”
I reached out and took his hand. His scarred fingers curled around mine with reverence.
“Do you see me?” I asked, voice small despite my effort.
“Yes,” he said, and his certainty made me want to weep. “I see all of you.”
The next words left my mouth before fear could stop them. “I think I’m falling in love with you.”
Silence struck the room like lightning.
We were in South Carolina. In 1856. In a world built on cruelty dressed as law. There was no space for what I’d just admitted.
Isaiah’s face tightened with something like grief. “Clara,” he said carefully, “you can’t.”
“Why?” I demanded, and the desperation in my voice startled me. “We’re already living in scandal’s shadow. My father already put us together. What difference does love make?”
Leave a Comment